Writing 2: Write for an Academic Discussion

Learn to post a clear, well-supported opinion with a new idea on an online class forum in 10 minutes.

  • Intermediate
  • 18 min
  • 10 questions
  • Lesson 7 of 10

In this lesson you will learn

  • Know how the task is built and how it is scored
  • Write a 120–150-word response with a five-part template
  • Refer to classmates' posts and add a new argument
  • Split 10 minutes between planning, writing and checking

The Write for an Academic Discussion task has existed since 2023 and did not change in the 2026 update — so older preparation materials are still useful here. On an online class forum you read a professor's question and two short posts by students, then write your own opinion. You have 10 minutes. According to ETS, an effective response contains at least 100 words.

What the task looks like

  1. The professor's post: briefly introduces the topic and asks an opinion question.
  2. Two students' posts: usually support different positions briefly.
  3. Your post: you state and support your opinion and make your own contribution to the discussion.
ScoreWhat the rater sees (simplified)
5A relevant, very clear contribution; well-developed explanations and examples; varied structures and precise words; almost no errors
4A relevant contribution; adequately developed; ideas easy to follow; few errors
3Mostly relevant; part of the explanation is missing or unclear; noticeable errors
2Ideas poorly developed or only partly relevant; limited language, many errors
1Few or no coherent ideas; language mostly borrowed from the prompt
0Blank, off-topic, not in English or entirely copied
Based on ETS's official scoring guide, in our own words.

Sign up free to keep reading

The rest of the lesson, the quiz and your notes open with an Educora account. Signing up takes a minute, and your progress is saved on all your devices.

A five-part template

  1. Position + reference

    Name one of the students and state your position in one sentence: While Kamran makes a good point about…, I believe…

  2. Main reason

    One clear reason — ideally a new one the students did not give: My main reason is that…

  3. Explanation

    Show in 1–2 sentences why the reason is true.

  4. A specific example

    Personal experience or a realistic situation: For example, in my statistics course…

  5. Answer the other side and conclude

    Briefly answer the other student's concern and reinforce your position in one sentence: In this way, …

How to split the 10 minutes

TimeWhat you do
0:00–1:00Read the question and both posts, choose a side
1:00–2:00Plan: note your reason and example in 3–4 words
2:00–8:30Write with the template (120–150 words)
8:30–10:00Check: articles, tenses, agreement, spelling

Practice: a prompt and a model answer

Problem

Set a 10-minute timer and write your response.

Your professor is teaching a class on education. Write a post that responds to the professor's question. In your post, express and support your opinion and add your own contribution to the discussion. An effective response will contain at least 100 words.

Dr. Morgan: Many universities are rethinking how they assess students. Some instructors now replace the traditional final exam with a semester-long project, such as a research report or a group presentation. Which do you think is a better way to measure what students have learned: a final exam or a semester-long project? Why?

Kamran: I prefer projects. In a real job, nobody asks you to memorize facts for a three-hour test. A project shows whether you can actually use what you learned, and you get feedback along the way.

Elena: I think final exams are fairer. In group projects, one or two students often do most of the work, but everyone gets the same grade. An exam measures each person's own knowledge.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Model answer (about 150 words):
I understand Elena's concern about unfair group work, but I still believe a semester-long project is the better way to measure learning. My main reason is that a project shows how deeply a student understands the material, not just how much they can remember under pressure. For example, in my statistics course last year, I had to collect survey data from other students and analyze it myself. Choosing the right methods and explaining unexpected results taught me far more than any exam question could. As for students who do not contribute, this problem can be solved rather than used as an argument against projects: instructors can ask each member to submit a short individual report and grade part of the work separately. In this way, projects keep their main advantage, which is showing what students can actually do, while remaining fair to everyone.

Analysis: sentence 1 — position and a reference to Elena; sentence 2 — the main reason (deep understanding versus memory — a different angle from Kamran's “real job” argument); sentences 3–4 — a personal example; sentence 5 — a concrete solution to Elena's objection (the new contribution); sentence 6 — conclusion. Language: but I still believe, As for, rather than, In this way, and the relative clause which is….
FunctionPhrases
Referring to a classmateI see Kamran's point that …, but … / Elena raises a valid concern about …
Giving an opinionIn my view, … / I am convinced that …
Adding a new ideaWhat neither of my classmates mentioned is …
Giving an exampleFor instance, when I … / A good example of this is …
ConcludingFor these reasons, … / In this way, …
1 / 8

Remember

  • The task is unchanged since 2023: a professor's question + two students + your post, 10 minutes.
  • According to ETS, an effective response has at least 100 words; 120–150 is a realistic target.
  • Template: position + reference → reason → explanation → example → answer the other side and conclude.
  • Don't repeat the students — add a new reason or solution to the discussion.
  • A 5 needs clarity, well-developed ideas and varied language — not perfection.
Spotted a mistake or something inaccurate in this lesson?

Check yourself

10 questions. Every correct answer earns XP.

Question 1 / 10

Question 1 / 10. How much time do you have for Write for an Academic Discussion?

TOEFL iBT Writing — Topic test 1: Write for an Academic Discussion

1 questions · 10 min

Start the test

TOEFL iBT Writing — Topic test 2: Write for an Academic Discussion

1 questions · 10 min

Start the test

TOEFL iBT Writing — Topic test 3: Write for an Academic Discussion

1 questions · 10 min

Start the test