“Most dentists recommend our toothpaste — so it must be the best.” “If you don't sign up for our course, you'll fail every exam.” Every day we meet arguments in adverts, in the news, on social media and in class. Logic gives us tools to test whether a conclusion really follows.
What is an argument?
ArgumentDefinition
A piece of reasoning in which one or more statements (premises) are offered as reasons for another statement (the conclusion). In logic, an argument is not a quarrel but a justification.
Often one premise of an argument is left unstated — it is a hidden assumption. In “Aysel won the olympiad, so she is good at maths”, the hidden premise is: “Olympiad winners are good at maths.” Critical thinking starts with bringing hidden assumptions into the open and checking them.
Deduction and induction, validity and soundness
In a deductive argument, if the premises are true, the conclusion must be true. In an inductive argument the premises only make the conclusion probable: “Every swan I have seen so far was white, so all swans are white.” There is also abduction — inference to the best explanation: a detective looks at the clues and chooses the most plausible explanation.
A deductive argument is valid if it is impossible for the premises to be true and the conclusion false. Validity depends on the argument's form, not on whether its statements are true. An argument is sound if it is valid and all its premises are true.
| Argument | Valid? | Premises true? | Sound? |
|---|---|---|---|
| All humans are mortal. Socrates is human. So Socrates is mortal. | yes | yes | yes |
| All fish can fly. A shark is a fish. So a shark can fly. | yes | no (the first) | no |
| All cats are mammals. Tom is a mammal. So Tom is a cat. | no | possibly | no |
Argument forms
Let P and Q be statements; P → Q means “if P, then Q”, and ¬P means “not P”. Modus ponens: P → Q; P; therefore Q. Modus tollens: P → Q; ¬Q; therefore ¬P. Both are valid. Two forms that look very similar, however, are formal fallacies: affirming the consequent and denying the antecedent.
| P | Q | P → Q |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 | 1 |
| 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 0 | 1 | 1 |
| 0 | 0 | 1 |
Affirming the consequent — invalid
P → Q
Q
∴ PModus ponens — valid
P → Q
P
∴ QDenying the antecedent — invalid
P → Q
¬P
∴ ¬QModus tollens — valid
P → Q
¬Q
∴ ¬PWhere
- P → Q
- “if P, then Q” (implication)
- ¬Q → ¬P
- the contrapositive: “if not Q, then not P”
- ≡
- equivalence: both statements always have the same truth value
Modus tollens rests on exactly this. Careful: Q → P (the converse) and ¬P → ¬Q (the inverse) are different statements.
Interactive
Informal fallacies
| Fallacy | What it does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Ad hominem | attacks the person instead of the argument | “You can't talk about ecology — you come to school by car.” |
| Straw man | distorts the opponent's view and attacks the distorted version | “You want less homework? So you don't want to study at all!” |
| False dilemma | offers only two options when more exist | “Either you're with us or you're against us.” |
| Slippery slope | claims without evidence that a small step will lead to disaster | “If we allow phones at break, soon nobody will study.” |
| Appeal to popularity | treats something as true because many believe it | “Millions of people use it, so it must be right.” |
| Appeal to irrelevant authority | cites a famous person who is not an expert in the field | “A famous footballer says this medicine works.” |
| Hasty generalisation | draws a general conclusion from too few cases | “I met two rude drivers — all drivers in this city are rude.” |
| Post hoc (after it, therefore because of it) | takes a sequence in time for a cause | “I wore my lucky shirt and we won — the shirt did it.” |
| Circular reasoning | the conclusion is already assumed in a premise | “He is trustworthy because he says he is honest.” |
Thought exercise: analyse the argument
Problem
Murad says: “Every successful person I know wakes up at 5 a.m. My cousin wakes up at 5 and she is successful. So if you want to succeed, you must wake up at 5 a.m.” Find the premises, the conclusion, the type of reasoning and the fallacies.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) Premises: the successful people he knows wake up at 5; so does his cousin.
3) The reasoning is inductive — a general rule drawn from a few cases.
4) Fallacies: hasty generalisation (a small, selected sample); treating things that occur together as cause and effect; jumping from “some are like this” to “it is necessary”.
5) Counterexamples: successful people who wake up late.
6) A stronger version: “Some successful people wake up early; a regular sleep schedule may help some people.”
- 4th century BC
Aristotle's Organon: the theory of the syllogism
- 3rd century BC
The Stoics (Chrysippus) develop the logic of propositions
- 11th century
The logic sections of Ibn Sina's Book of Healing become widely studied in the Islamic world
- 1854
George Boole, The Laws of Thought — logic becomes algebra
- 1879
Gottlob Frege lays the foundations of modern formal logic
- 1937
Claude Shannon applies Boolean logic to electrical circuits
This idea became a foundation of computers.
- 1.The statements that give reasons in an argument are called .
- 2.An argument is if its conclusion must be true when its premises are true.
- 3.A valid argument whose premises are all true is .
- 4.“If P then Q; not Q; therefore not P” is modus .
- 5.Attacking the person instead of the argument is called ad .
- 6.Distorting an opponent's view to attack it easily is the man fallacy.
Remember
- An argument = premises + conclusion; indicator words help to find them, and hidden assumptions must be checked too.
- Deduction (if valid) guarantees the conclusion; induction only makes it probable.
- Validity = correct form; soundness = validity + true premises.
- Modus ponens and modus tollens are valid; affirming the consequent and denying the antecedent are fallacies; P → Q ≡ ¬Q → ¬P.
- Informal fallacies (ad hominem, straw man, false dilemma, slippery slope and others) persuade without good reasons.