In early 19th-century England almost all peppered moths were pale, and they were hard to see on tree bark covered in lichen. As soot from factories blackened the trees, dark moths became more and more common around industrial cities, and by the end of the century they were the majority. The moths had not changed their colour — the population had changed. The reason is natural selection.
The idea of evolution
EvolutionDefinition
The gradual change of living things over many generations, through which adaptations develop and new species arise.
Put simply, evolution is a change in the “make-up” of a population over time. Think of a school photo taken every year: over the years the faces in the photo change, yet no pupil turns into someone else — some leave and new ones arrive. In evolution, too, individual living things do not change: from generation to generation some traits become more common and others rarer.
- 1809
Jean-Baptiste Lamarck puts forward the first full theory of evolution
He believed that features acquired during life are passed on; this idea was later shown to be wrong.
- 1831–1836
Charles Darwin sails around the world on HMS Beagle
On the Galápagos Islands he finds finches with different beaks on different islands.
- 1858
Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace present the idea of natural selection together
- 1859
Darwin publishes On the Origin of Species
How natural selection works
Variation
Individuals of a species differ from one another in colour, size, speed and so on. These differences come from mutations and sexual reproduction.
Inheritance
Some of these differences are passed on to offspring through genes.
Struggle for existence
Organisms produce far more offspring than can survive, and there is not enough food and shelter for all.
Selection
Individuals better suited to the environment are more likely to survive and have more offspring.
Result
Over generations the useful traits spread through the population, and the population changes.
Explain the moths
Problem
Use the theory of natural selection to explain why dark moths became common where trees were blackened by soot. What would you expect after the air became clean again?
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2. On blackened bark the pale moths stood out, so birds caught more of them.
3. Dark moths survived and bred more often, so their share grew with each generation.
4. When the air was cleaned and the bark became pale again, selection worked the other way: in the second half of the 20th century pale moths became common again.
Selection in numbers
Problem
A wood blackened by soot has 100 moths: 50 pale and 50 dark. Birds catch half of the pale moths but only one in ten of the dark ones. The survivors' young look like their parents. What share of the next generation will be dark?
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) The next generation keeps the same proportions: the share of dark moths is 45 ÷ 70 ≈ 64% (it was 50%).
3) Repeating the same calculation gives about 76%, then 85% dark. No moth changed its colour — the dark moths simply left more young.
| Question | Lamarck's idea (wrong) | Darwin's idea (right) |
|---|---|---|
| Where does the long neck come from? | A giraffe stretches its neck to reach leaves, and the neck grows longer | Giraffes are born with necks of different lengths |
| Who survives? | Everyone; their necks just get longer | Long-necked ones find more leaves in a drought and survive more often |
| What do the young inherit? | The long neck “earned” during life | The genes for a long neck: only inherited differences are passed on |
Where
- p
- the frequency of the dominant allele A
- q
- the frequency of the recessive allele a
- p², 2pq, q²
- the shares of the genotypes AA, Aa and aa
The Hardy–Weinberg law. In a large population with random mating and no selection, mutation or migration, allele frequencies stay the same from generation to generation. That is why evolution is also defined as “a change in allele frequencies”: when any of these conditions is broken, the population evolves.
How many carriers are there?
Problem
In a population one child in 10,000 has albinism (aa). The Hardy–Weinberg law holds. What share of the population are heterozygous carriers of the a allele (Aa)?
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2pq = 2 · 0.99 · 0.01 = 0.0198 ≈ 2% — about one person in 50.
A surprising result: albinism affects one person in 10,000, but one in 50 is a carrier. Most recessive alleles “hide” in heterozygotes, where selection hardly touches them.
Where does resistance come from?
Problem
During an infection the body contains 10¹⁰ bacteria. Because of mutations, about one bacterium in 10⁸ is resistant to an antibiotic. 1) How many resistant bacteria are there before treatment? 2) The antibiotic kills the rest, and the resistant ones double every 30 minutes. About how many are there after 10 hours? 3) What is the probability that a bacterium is resistant to two different antibiotics at once?
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) 10 hours = 20 doublings: 100 · 2²⁰ ≈ 100 · 10⁶ = 10⁸.
3) The mutations are independent, so the probabilities multiply: 10⁻⁸ · 10⁻⁸ = 10⁻¹⁶ — even among 10¹⁰ bacteria such a cell is very unlikely. That is why tuberculosis and HIV are treated with several drugs at once.
Selection does not create the mutation; it picks one that already exists. S. Luria and M. Delbrück proved this in bacteria in 1943.
Adaptations
- Camouflage: the sandy coat of the goitered gazelle makes it hard to spot on semi-desert plains.
- Saving water: a cactus's leaves have become spines, which cuts water loss, and water is stored in its fleshy stem.
- Coping with cold: the Caspian seal's thick layer of blubber protects it from cold water, and its pups are born in winter on the ice of the northern Caspian.
- Matching the food: among Galápagos finches, seed-crackers have thick, strong beaks, while insect-eaters have thin, pointed ones.
When populations of a species are separated for a long time — by mountains or by sea, for example — each changes independently in its own environment. In time they become so different that they can no longer interbreed, and a new species has formed.
The birth of a new species can be compared with languages. Long ago much of Europe spoke Latin. As peoples lived apart, the language changed in its own way in each place, and centuries later Italian, Spanish and French grew out of it — today their speakers understand each other only with difficulty. In the same way, when populations are separated for a long time by mountains or a sea, each changes in its own environment. One day they differ so much that they can no longer interbreed — and a new species has formed.
The main test of a new species is reproductive isolation: the populations cannot interbreed, or their offspring are sterile. A mule, the hybrid of a horse (2n = 64) and a donkey (2n = 62), has 63 chromosomes: they cannot pair up in meiosis, so mules are usually sterile. When mountains or a sea split populations, speciation is geographic, or allopatric. In plants a new species can even appear in one generation through an increase in the number of chromosome sets — polyploidy: bread wheat, for example, is hexaploid, 6n = 42.
Evidence for evolution
| Evidence | Example |
|---|---|
| Fossils | Older rock layers contain simpler life; Archaeopteryx combines features of reptiles and birds |
| Homologous organs | A human arm, a whale's flipper and a bat's wing share the same bone plan |
| Vestigial organs | The human tailbone; remnants of hip bones in whales |
| Embryology | Early vertebrate embryos look very alike, and all have gill-slit-like structures |
| DNA comparison | Human and chimpanzee DNA is about 98% the same: the more closely related two species are, the more similar their DNA |
- Homologous organs are like different toys built from the same construction kit: a human arm, a whale's flipper and a bat's wing do different jobs, but their “parts” — the bones — are the same. This shows that they come from a common ancestor.
- Vestigial organs are like a button left in an old car that no longer switches anything on: the human tailbone is what remains of our distant ancestors' tail.
- Fossils are like the pages of a history book: as a rule, the deeper a rock layer lies, the older it is.
Modern evolutionary biology finds its most precise evidence in DNA. Even 98% similarity is not a small difference: 1–2% of 3 billion base pairs means tens of millions of changes. If mutations build up at a roughly constant rate, the number of differences between two species' DNA is proportional to the time since they split from a common ancestor — this is the idea of the molecular clock (1960s). Such estimates are checked against fossils.
The molecular clock
Problem
In one gene, species A and B differ at 12 nucleotide positions, and species A and C at 36 positions. Fossils show that A and B split about 6 million years ago. If the mutation rate is constant, when did A and C split?
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
6 million years × 3 = about 18 million years ago.
Check: after a split both lineages change independently, so each lineage gains 12 ÷ 2 = 6 changes in 6 million years — 1 per million years; then for A and C: 2 · 18 · 1 = 36 ✓
Remember
- Evolution is the gradual change of living things over generations; its main mechanism is natural selection.
- Natural selection needs inherited variation, more offspring than can survive and a struggle for existence.
- Populations evolve, not individuals; acquired traits are not inherited.
- Darwin published On the Origin of Species in 1859.
- Evidence for evolution: fossils, homologous and vestigial organs, embryology and DNA comparison.