In November 2024 Baku hosted COP29, the UN Climate Change Conference, with delegations from almost every country in the world. Azerbaijan has been a member of the OSCE (then the CSCE) since January 1992, of the UN since 2 March 1992 and of the Council of Europe since 2001, and it served as a non-permanent member of the UN Security Council in 2012–2013. How did sovereign states, often rivals, learn to build permanent institutions together — and why did the first attempt, the League of Nations, fail?
The 19th century: congresses and “technical” unions
After Napoleon, the “Concert of Europe” (1815) meant that the great powers settled crises at congresses, but it had no permanent bodies. The first permanent intergovernmental organizations were technical: the Central Commission for the Navigation of the Rhine (1815), the International Telegraph Union (1865, today's International Telecommunication Union) and the Universal Postal Union (1874). The International Committee of the Red Cross (1863) and the first Geneva Convention (1864) laid the foundations of modern humanitarian law. The Hague Peace Conferences (1899, 1907) created the Permanent Court of Arbitration.
The League of Nations (1920–1946)
The Covenant of the League of Nations formed Part I of the Treaty of Versailles; the League began work on 10 January 1920, with its seat in Geneva. Its central idea was collective security: under Article 16, sanctions were to be imposed on an aggressor. Decisions of the Assembly and the Council generally required unanimity. The United States never joined, because the Senate refused to ratify the Treaty of Versailles; Germany joined in 1926 and left in 1933, Japan left in 1933 and Italy in 1937; the USSR was admitted in 1934 and expelled in December 1939 after it attacked Finland.
The League had successes too: in 1921 it settled the Åland Islands dispute (the islands stayed with Finland, with autonomy), from 1922 it issued “Nansen passports” to refugees, and the International Labour Organization, founded in 1919, drew up labour standards. But in the 1930s the League could not stop aggression by great powers: in 1931 Japan occupied Manchuria, and when the Lytton Commission's report (1932) condemned it, Japan left the League; in 1935 Italy invaded Ethiopia, and sanctions were imposed but did not include oil. The League was formally dissolved in April 1946 and handed its assets to the UN.
Collective securityDefinition
A system in which aggression against one state is treated as aggression against all members, who respond jointly; unlike an alliance, it is aimed not at an outside enemy but at any member of the system that breaks the peace.
The United Nations
The road to the UN ran through the Declaration by United Nations of 1 January 1942, the Dumbarton Oaks draft of 1944 and the veto formula agreed at Yalta. At the San Francisco conference the Charter was signed on 26 June 1945, and it entered into force on 24 October 1945. The main organs are the General Assembly, where every member has one vote; the Security Council, which since 1965 has 15 members (5 permanent — China, France, Russia (the USSR until 1991), the United Kingdom and the United States — and 10 non-permanent members elected for two years); the Secretariat headed by the Secretary-General; the International Court of Justice in The Hague; and the Economic and Social Council. Under Chapter VII of the Charter the Security Council can take decisions binding on all members — sanctions and the authorisation of force. The UN system also includes the World Health Organization (1948), UNESCO (1945), and the International Monetary Fund and World Bank created at Bretton Woods (1944); peacekeeping missions have been deployed since 1948.
Where
- Yes
- the number of the 15 Security Council members voting in favour
- P5 “No”
- negative votes cast by the five permanent members (a veto); abstaining is not a veto
A Security Council decision on substantive (non-procedural) matters. On procedural matters 9 votes are enough and there is no veto. The practice that a permanent member's abstention is not a veto dates from the 1940s and was confirmed by the International Court of Justice in 1971.
Where
- Yes + No
- “members present and voting”; abstentions are not counted
A General Assembly decision on important questions (peace and security, admission of new members, the budget); other questions need a simple majority. Assembly resolutions are, as a rule, recommendations.
Example 1. The Security Council and the General Assembly
Problem
Draft resolutions in the Security Council: a) 13 yes, 1 no (a permanent member), 1 abstention; b) 10 yes, 0 no, 5 abstentions (two of them permanent members); c) 8 yes, 0 no, 7 abstentions. d) An important question in the General Assembly: 180 members present, 110 yes, 50 no, 20 abstentions. Which are adopted?
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
b) 10 ≥ 9 ✓, no permanent member voted no (abstention is not a veto) → adopted.
c) 8 < 9 → not adopted, even without a veto.
d) Present and voting: 110 + 50 = 160; ⅔ · 160 ≈ 106.7 → at least 107 votes are needed; 110 ≥ 107 → adopted.
Typical mistake: counting the abstentions gives ⅔ · 180 = 120, and the resolution would wrongly seem to fail.
| Feature | League of Nations | United Nations |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1920 (Covenant part of the Treaty of Versailles) | 1945 (Charter signed in San Francisco) |
| Great powers | the USA never joined; Germany, Japan and Italy left; the USSR was expelled | all are members; five hold permanent seats with a veto |
| Decisions | mostly by unanimity | by majority; permanent members' veto in the Security Council |
| Enforcement | sanctions only, no forces of its own | Chapter VII: binding decisions, sanctions, authorisation of force; peacekeeping |
| Outcome | failed to stop aggression in the 1930s; dissolved in 1946 | 193 members; the veto sometimes paralyses the Council, but the organization is universal |
European integration and regional organizations
In 1949 the Council of Europe was founded in Strasbourg to promote human rights, democracy and the rule of law; the European Convention on Human Rights of 1950 is upheld by the European Court of Human Rights. On 9 May 1950 the French foreign minister Robert Schuman proposed placing French and German coal and steel production under a common authority. With the Treaty of Paris (1951) six states — France, the Federal Republic of Germany, Italy, Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg — created the European Coal and Steel Community; the Treaties of Rome (1957) established the European Economic Community and Euratom. The Maastricht Treaty of 1992 (in force from 1 November 1993) created the European Union; the euro was introduced in 1999 (notes and coins from 2002), the Treaty of Lisbon entered into force in 2009, and the United Kingdom left the Union on 31 January 2020.
Interactive
In the Council of the EU many decisions are taken by qualified majority (since 2014 a “double majority”). Other regional organizations also emerged in the era of the Cold War and decolonization: NATO (4 April 1949, 12 founders; Article 5 — collective defence; Greece and Türkiye joined in 1952), the Warsaw Pact (1955–1991), the CSCE, which grew out of the Helsinki Final Act of 1975 (the OSCE since 1995), the Organisation of African Unity (1963; the African Union since 2002) and ASEAN (1967).
Where
- States
- share of member states voting in favour; with 27 members, 0.55 · 27 = 14.85 → at least 15
- Population
- those states' share of the EU population
Qualified majority in the Council of the EU (the “double majority”, Treaty of Lisbon). A blocking minority must include at least 4 states representing more than 35% of the population; if fewer than 4 states vote against, the qualified majority is deemed reached.
Example 2. Qualified majority in the Council of the EU (27 members)
Problem
Is the proposal adopted? a) 16 states in favour, representing 62% of the population. b) 14 states in favour, 70% of the population. c) 24 states in favour with 62% of the population; 3 large states against with 38%.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
b) States: 14 < 15 ✗ → not adopted (even with 70% of the population).
c) States: 24 ≥ 15 ✓; population 62% < 65% — normally not enough. But only 3 states are against, and a blocking minority needs at least 4 → deemed adopted.
Conclusion: the “rule of four” stops a handful of the largest states from blocking a decision on their own.
Interactive
- 1815
Congress of Vienna; the Concert of Europe; the Rhine Commission
- 1863–1865
The Red Cross; the first Geneva Convention; the Telegraph Union
- 1899
The first Hague Peace Conference
- 1920
The League of Nations begins work
- 1945
The UN Charter is signed and enters into force
- 1949
NATO and the Council of Europe are founded
- 1951
The European Coal and Steel Community
- 1957
Treaties of Rome — the EEC
- 1975
The Helsinki Final Act (CSCE)
- 1992
The Maastricht Treaty; Azerbaijan joins the UN
- 2001
Azerbaijan joins the Council of Europe
- 2009
The Treaty of Lisbon enters into force
- 2020
The United Kingdom leaves the EU
- 2024
COP29 in Baku
- 1.The UN Charter entered into force on 24 October .
- 2.The Security Council has permanent members.
- 3.A Security Council resolution needs at least votes in favour.
- 4.The seat of the League of Nations was in .
- 5.The European Union was created by the Treaty of 1992.
Remember
- International organizations grew out of 19th-century congresses and technical unions (the Rhine Commission, the postal and telegraph unions).
- The League of Nations (1920–1946) failed to stop aggression in the 1930s because of unanimity, the absence of great powers and weak sanctions.
- A UN Security Council decision needs 9 yes votes and no “no” vote from a permanent member; abstention is not a veto.
- European integration grew from the ECSC (1951) through the Treaties of Rome (1957) to Maastricht (1992); membership rose from 6 to 28 and is now 27.
- Qualified majority in the Council of the EU: 55% of states and 65% of the population; a blocking minority needs at least 4 states.