The end of the 7th century BC, a village in Attica. In the middle of a peasant’s field stands a stone pillar saying that the land is pledged to a noble for a debt. If the peasant does not repay in time, he will lose his land, then himself and his children — they will be sold as slaves. How could justice be restored in such a society? Over a century Athens tried four answers to this question, while Sparta went a completely different way.
Athens: the demos against the nobles
Athens lay in the region of Attica, near the sea; its people were Ionians. Royal power disappeared early here and government passed to the nobles — this was aristocracy, «the rule of the best». The archons, elected every year from among the nobles, ran the state, while the council of the Areopagus, made up of former archons, watched over the laws and judged grave crimes. The laws were not written down: noble judges interpreted custom in their own favour.
The demos was discontented. Peasants fell into debt slavery, and land piled up in the hands of the nobles. Traders who had grown rich through crafts and commerce could not share in power, because offices were given by birth. The demos demanded two things: the cancelling of debts and a share-out of land, and written laws.
In 621 BC the nobles had to give way: the lawgiver Draco drew up the first written laws of Athens. This was a step forward — a judge could no longer interpret the law as he pleased. But the laws were extremely harsh: even stealing vegetables or fruit was punished by death. Later people said that Draco’s laws were written not in ink but in blood, and «draconian» still describes excessively harsh measures today. Above all, Draco did not touch debt slavery, so the struggle went on.
The reforms of Solon (594 BC)
On the brink of civil war, the Athenians gave wide powers to Solon, elected archon in 594 BC. Solon came from a noble family, but he had engaged in trade, travelled widely and was known for his poems; both sides trusted him. His first and most important measure was the cancellation of debts: the debt stones were pulled out of the fields, debt slavery was banned, Athenians enslaved for debt were freed and those sold abroad were brought back. The Greeks called this law «the shaking off of burdens».
Solon divided the citizens into four classes by wealth, not by birth — according to the yearly harvest from their land. Only the wealthy classes could be elected to the highest offices, but even the poorest citizens took part in the assembly and gained the right to sit in the people’s court. A Council of Four Hundred was set up. Solon also encouraged crafts and trade: a father who had not taught his son a trade could not demand his support in old age, and no farm produce except olive oil could be exported from Attica.
Solon’s reforms did not fully satisfy anyone: the poor had hoped for a share-out of land, and the nobles regretted what they had lost. Even so, they laid the foundation of Athenian democracy: a citizen could no longer lose his freedom, and political rights depended on wealth, not birth.
Tyranny and the reforms of Cleisthenes
After Solon the quarrels flared up again. Taking advantage of them, Pisistratus seized power by force in 560 BC. The Greeks called a ruler who came to power by force rather than by lawful means a tyrant, and his rule a tyranny; at first the word did not mean «cruel». Pisistratus was driven out twice but returned and held power until his death in 527 BC. He lent money to poor peasants, built temples and a water supply, organised great festivals, and did not abolish Solon’s laws. Tyranny weakened the power of the nobles and strengthened the demos.
Pisistratus’s sons lost the people’s favour: Hipparchus was killed in 514 BC, and Hippias, who had grown harsh, was driven out in 510 BC with Spartan help. In 508/507 BC Cleisthenes, backed by the demos, carried out new reforms. He divided Attica into 10 territorial tribes (phylai) instead of the old kinship groups: each tribe included people from the city, the coast and the inland villages, so the noble clans lost their grip on their home districts. A Council of Five Hundred was formed, 50 men from each tribe. Cleisthenes also introduced ostracism: the assembly wrote the name of a man it thought dangerous to the state on potsherds (ostraka), and the man with the most votes was sent out of the country for 10 years. These reforms established democracy in Athens.
DemocracyDefinition
From Greek «demos» (people) and «kratos» (power): a form of government in which the citizens make the main decisions in their assembly. In Athens citizens were adult men only; women, metics and slaves had no political rights.
Sparta — a military state
Sparta lay in the south of the Peloponnese, in Laconia; it had been founded by the Dorians who came there. The Spartans conquered the local people and then, in long wars, neighbouring Messenia. The people of the conquered lands became helots: they were counted as the property of the state, farmed the Spartans’ plots and handed over part of the harvest. The helots outnumbered the Spartans many times over and often rose in revolt. The perioeci — «those who live around» — were free, worked as craftsmen and traders and served in the army, but had no political rights.
To keep the helots down, Sparta subordinated its whole life to war; according to tradition, these rules were created by the lawgiver Lycurgus. Full Spartan citizens did nothing but soldiering; crafts and trade were forbidden to them. Heavy iron money was used to stop people piling up wealth. From the age of 7 boys were taken from their families and trained hard in groups: they learned to bear cold, hunger and pain and to speak briefly and to the point — the word «laconic» comes from this. Girls did sports too, and Spartan women had more freedom and property rights than women in other poleis.
Sparta was ruled by two kings, who led the army in war and served as priests. Real power, however, lay with the Gerousia — the two kings and 28 elders over the age of 60 — and with five ephors elected every year, who even supervised the kings. Spartans over 30 gathered in the assembly (apella) and accepted or rejected proposals by shouting, without debate. In the 6th century BC Sparta united most of the Peloponnesian poleis under its leadership in the Peloponnesian League and had the strongest land army in Greece.
«Either with this or on this!»
Interactive
«The inequality between rich and poor had reached its peak. All the common people were in debt to the rich: some farmed their land and handed over a sixth of the crop, others borrowed on the security of their own bodies and, unable to pay, were enslaved — some at home, some sold to foreign lands. Many were forced to sell their children or flee their homeland.
The wisest men of the city turned to a man who had no share either in the wrongs of the rich or in the needs of the poor. He was elected archon, and by his first law he cancelled existing debts and from then on forbade lending on the security of a person’s body. The people called this law «the shaking off of burdens».»
Source tasks
Problem
1) Identify the unnamed reformer, his polis and the year of the reform.
2) Explain one economic and one political cause of these reforms.
3) Write two results of these reforms that the text does not mention.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) Economic: debt slavery and the concentration of land in noble hands were ruining the peasants. Political: the struggle between demos and nobles had brought the city to the edge of civil war; enslaved peasants also weakened the army, since hoplites were free citizens. Marks: both causes explained — 1; both unexplained — ⅔; one explained — ½; one unexplained — ⅓.
3) Results not in the text: citizens were divided into four classes by wealth; the poorest gained the right to take part in the assembly and the court; the Council of Four Hundred was formed; crafts and trade were encouraged; since land was not redistributed, the struggle went on and led to the tyranny of Pisistratus. Marks: two results — 1; one — ½.
Chronology, tables and exam-type tasks
- 8th–7th centuries BC
Sparta conquers Messenia
The Messenians become helots.
- 621 BC
The laws of Draco
- 594 BC
The reforms of Solon
- 560 BC
Pisistratus seizes power
- 6th century BC
The Peloponnesian League is formed
- 527 BC
Death of Pisistratus; power passes to his sons
- 514 BC
Hipparchus is killed
- 510 BC
Hippias is driven out of Athens
- 508/507 BC
Reforms of Cleisthenes in Athens
10 tribes, Council of 500, ostracism.
- 487 BC
Ostracism is used for the first time
| Person | Date | Deeds |
|---|---|---|
| Lycurgus | legendary | traditional creator of the Spartan order |
| Draco | 621 BC | the first written, harsh laws of Athens |
| Solon | 594 BC | debts cancelled, debt slavery banned, 4 classes, Council of 400 |
| Pisistratus | 560–527 BC | tyranny; loans to peasants, building, festivals |
| Hippias | expelled in 510 BC | son of Pisistratus, last tyrant of Athens |
| Cleisthenes | 508/507 BC | 10 territorial tribes, Council of 500, ostracism |
| Feature | Athens | Sparta |
|---|---|---|
| Location, people | Attica; Ionians | Laconia (Peloponnese); Dorians |
| Government | democracy: assembly, Council of 500 | oligarchy (rule of the few): two kings, Gerousia, ephors |
| Dependent people | slaves, metics | helots (state-owned), perioeci |
| Economy | crafts, sea trade, olives and vines | land farmed by helots; trade forbidden to Spartans |
| Money | silver coins | iron money |
| Upbringing | reading, writing, music, sport, public speaking | harsh military training from age 7 |
| Common features | polis; slave labour; political rights only for male citizens; an assembly | polis; slave labour; political rights only for male citizens; an assembly |
| Cause | Result |
|---|---|
| Unwritten laws, arbitrary judges | the laws of Draco (621 BC) |
| Debt slavery, land concentrated among the nobles | the reforms of Solon (594 BC) |
| Strife continuing after Solon | the tyranny of Pisistratus (560 BC) |
| The harsh rule of Hippias | his expulsion (510 BC) and the reforms of Cleisthenes |
| Creation of territorial tribes | the influence of noble clans broken |
| The great number of helots and fear of revolt | Sparta turned into a military state |
Exam-type task: «unlike X»
Problem
Unlike Athens, Sparta was characterised by:
1. having two kings
2. the use of slave labour
3. the use of iron money
4. a ban on trade for citizens
5. having an assembly
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Step 2: the rest belong only to Sparta: two kings (1), iron money (3), the ban on trade (4).
Answer: 1, 3, 4.
Exam-type task: chronology
Problem
Put the events in chronological order:
1. the reforms of Cleisthenes
2. the laws of Draco
3. Pisistratus seizes power
4. the reforms of Solon
5. Hippias is driven out
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Step 2: with BC dates the larger number is earlier; 5 and 1 are close — Cleisthenes reformed after the tyrant was expelled.
Answer: 2, 4, 3, 5, 1.
Exam-type task: matching
Problem
Match each reformer with his measure:
1. Draco
2. Solon
3. Cleisthenes
a. introduction of ostracism
b. abolition of debt slavery
c. the first written laws
d. military training of boys from age 7
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Step 2: Draco — the first written laws (1-c), Solon — cancellation of debts (2-b), Cleisthenes — ostracism (3-a).
Answer: 1-c, 2-b, 3-a.
Remember
- In Athens debt slavery and the arbitrary rule of the nobles caused a sharp struggle between demos and nobles.
- Draco (621 BC) wrote the laws down; Solon (594 BC) cancelled debts, banned debt slavery and divided citizens into four classes by wealth.
- The tyranny of Pisistratus (560–527 BC) weakened the nobles; Cleisthenes (508/507 BC) set up democracy with 10 territorial tribes, the Council of 500 and ostracism.
- Sparta became a military state to keep the helots down: two kings, the Gerousia, ephors, military training from age 7, iron money.
- Both poleis used slave labour and had an assembly, and political rights belonged only to male citizens.