March 1814. Russian troops enter Paris: a year after his defeat at Leipzig, Napoleon’s mastery over Europe is over, and Russia is the strongest land power of the continent. Only forty years later, in 1854, Sevastopol, Russia’s port on the Black Sea, lies under the fire of British and French ships. How did strength turn into weakness? The key to the answer is one word: serfdom.
SerfdomDefinition
A system binding the peasant to the land and to the landowner: the owner could sell the peasant, who owed barshchina (labour on the lord’s land) or obrok (payment in money or goods). The tsar’s power was limited by no elected body (absolute monarchy, autocracy).
Alexander I (1801–1825): reform plans and 1812
Domestic policy. At the start of his reign Alexander I prepared reforms: ministries replaced the old colleges (1802), and the decree on «free cultivators» (1803) allowed landowners to free peasants with land for a ransom, though few used it. On Speransky’s plan the State Council was created in 1810. Serfdom and autocracy stayed untouched; after the war policy hardened and military settlements were extended under General Arakcheyev.
The Patriotic War (1812). To punish Russia for evading the Continental Blockade, Napoleon crossed the Neman in June 1812 with an army of about half a million. The Russian army avoided a great battle and fell back; Kutuzov was named commander-in-chief. The battle near Borodino (7 September) ended with heavy losses and no clear winner. The Russians abandoned Moscow, and the city burned down.
Napoleon waited for peace talks that never came and began his retreat in October. The devastated Smolensk road, hunger, severe cold, partisan raids and the losses at the Berezina destroyed the «Grande Armée». Because the victory came from these conditions rather than from a decisive battle, it is called the «victory not won in battle». In 1813 the Russian army marched into Europe, Napoleon was beaten at the «Battle of the Nations» (Leipzig), and in 1814 Russian troops entered Paris. At the Congress of Vienna (1815) most of the Polish lands went to Russia: the tsar became King of Poland, and the country had its own constitution. Alexander I was the initiator of the «Holy Alliance» (see the lesson «The Napoleonic era and the Congress of Vienna»).
Interactive
The Decembrists and Nicholas I (1825–1855): «the gendarme of Europe»
The Decembrists. Young noble officers who had seen Europe in 1813–1814 felt Russia’s backwardness more sharply and founded secret societies: the Northern Society in St Petersburg and the Southern Society in Ukraine. N. Muravyov of the Northern Society proposed a constitutional monarchy; P. Pestel, head of the Southern Society («Russian Justice»), proposed a republic and the abolition of serfdom.
In November 1825 Alexander I died unexpectedly, the succession was unclear, and his brother Nicholas I took the throne. On 14 December (Old Style) the rebels led troops to Senate Square, but their actions were uncoordinated, the elected «dictator» S. Trubetskoy never appeared, and the revolt was crushed by cannon fire. Pestel and four others were hanged, and most of the rest were exiled to Siberia. It was the first open armed action of noble revolutionaries against autocracy and serfdom.
Nicholas I (1825–1855). Fearing a repeat of the shock, the tsar tightened control: the Third Section, a political police, was created (1826), and censorship grew harsher. The education minister S. Uvarov made the formula «Orthodoxy, autocracy, nationality» the official ideology (1833). The first railways were built (St Petersburg–Moscow, 1851) and the industrial revolution began; but serfdom stayed untouched.
«The gendarme of Europe». Abroad Nicholas I defended the existing order against revolutions: in 1830–1831 he crushed the Polish uprising and abolished the country’s constitution, and in 1849 he helped Austria to put down the Hungarian revolution. That is why he was called «the gendarme of Europe». In the south Russia beat Iran (Treaty of Turkmenchay, 1828) and signed the Treaty of Edirne with the Ottomans (1829); see «The second Russo-Qajar war (1826–1828) and the Treaty of Turkmenchay».
The Crimean War (1853–1856)
The Ottoman weakness had made the great powers rivals for its inheritance — the «Eastern Question» (see the lesson «The Ottoman Empire in the 17th–18th centuries: stagnation, the Tulip Era and the Eastern Question»). Nicholas I called the Ottomans «the sick man» and proposed dividing them; Russia wanted a protectorate over the sultan’s Orthodox subjects and a leading place at the Holy Places. When the sultan refused, Russian troops entered Moldavia and Wallachia in 1853. Britain and France feared Russia’s growth in the Balkans and on the road to the Mediterranean.
In November 1853 Admiral Nakhimov’s squadron destroyed the Ottoman fleet in the harbour of Sinop. In March 1854 Britain and France entered the war on the Ottoman side (Sardinia joined in 1855). The Allies landed in the Crimea and besieged Sevastopol; the city held out for about a year, Admirals Kornilov and Nakhimov were killed in its defence, and it fell in September 1855. On the Caucasian front Russia took the fortress of Kars (1855). During the war Nicholas I died (1855) and Alexander II took the throne.
The Treaty of Paris (1856). The Black Sea was declared neutral: Russia and the Ottomans could keep no fleet or naval bases there. Russia gave southern Bessarabia at the mouth of the Danube to Moldavia, the Danubian principalities came under the guarantee of the great powers, and Russia’s right to protect the sultan’s Orthodox subjects was cancelled. Kars was returned to the Ottomans and Sevastopol to Russia. Russia got these clauses annulled only in 1870–1871.
Interactive
Alexander II (1855–1881): the Great Reforms
The Crimean defeat showed that an army and an industry resting on serfdom lagged behind: against the enemy’s steamships the Russian fleet was mostly sailing ships, and there were few railways. Also fearing peasant revolts, Alexander II began reforms; in history he is called the «Tsar Liberator».
The manifesto of 19 February 1861 abolished serfdom (3 March New Style). Peasants received personal freedom and an allotment of land for their farms, but they had to buy the land with a ransom: the state paid the landowner the value of the land and the peasant repaid this debt, with interest, to the state over about 49 years. Part of the land stayed with the landowner, and peasants remained bound to the village commune. The reform freed the peasant, but only half-way.
| Reform | Year | Content |
|---|---|---|
| Peasant | 1861 | serfdom abolished, redemption payments |
| Zemstvo | 1864 | elected local self-government: roads, schools, health |
| Judicial | 1864 | independent judges, open hearings, juries |
| Municipal | 1870 | elected city dumas |
| Military | 1874 | D. Milyutin: universal conscription, shorter service |
Abroad Alexander II crushed the Polish uprising (1863–1864), completed the conquest of the Caucasus and Central Asia (see «The conquest of the North Caucasus and Central Asia») and fought the Ottomans in 1877–1878. But the reforms stayed half-finished: the Narodniks («going to the people», 1874) and the terrorist organisation «People’s Will» (1879) rose against tsarism. On 1 March 1881 (Old Style) Alexander II was killed in an assassination in St Petersburg.
Alexander III (1881–1894): counter-reforms and the «prison of peoples»
Alexander III issued the «Manifesto on the inviolability of autocracy» (1881); his chief ideologist was K. Pobedonostsev, Over-Procurator of the Holy Synod. The statute on the «protection of state order» (1881) gave the police wide powers, university autonomy was abolished (1884), noble «land captains» were appointed in the villages (1889), and zemstvo and city self-government was restricted (1890, 1892). In the economy, however, industry grew fast: the building of the Trans-Siberian Railway began (1891), and the finance minister S. Witte (from 1892) speeded up industrialisation.
| Area | Alexander II | Alexander III |
|---|---|---|
| Peasants | serfdom abolished (1861) | land captains supervise peasants (1889) |
| Local government | elected zemstvos (1864) and dumas (1870) | rights restricted (1890, 1892) |
| Education | university autonomy (1863) | autonomy abolished (1884) |
«Prison of peoples»Definition
A phrase characterising the empire’s attitude to its non-Russian peoples (often linked with Lenin): the peoples were not equal in law, and policy meant Russification — spreading the Russian language and Orthodoxy. Historians dispute this verdict; Azerbaijani textbooks stress the colonial character of imperial policy.
In Poland, Russian was imposed after the 1863 uprising; Jews could not leave the Pale of Settlement and suffered pogroms in 1881–1882. In the Caucasus, Azerbaijanis were often called «Caucasian Tatars» in official papers and settlers were placed on their lands (see «Colonial rule and tsarist resettlement policy»). For the next period go to «Russia in the early 20th century: the 1905–1907 revolution and Stolypin’s reforms».
| Tsar | Years | Domestic policy | Foreign policy | Label |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alexander I | 1801–1825 | ministries (1802), State Council (1810), military settlements | 1812, Paris (1814), Congress of Vienna, Holy Alliance | the tsar who defeated Napoleon |
| Nicholas I | 1825–1855 | Third Section, censorship, Uvarov’s formula | Poland (1830–1831), Hungary (1849), Crimean War | «the gendarme of Europe» |
| Alexander II | 1855–1881 | 1861, zemstvo, judicial, military reforms | Peace of Paris (1856), Alaska (1867), 1877–1878 | «Tsar Liberator» |
| Alexander III | 1881–1894 | counter-reforms, Russification | alliance with France (1891–1894), Trans-Siberian | the «prison of peoples» policy |
| Cause | Result |
|---|---|
| Napoleon’s invasion and the march through Europe (1812–1814) | patriotic upsurge; officers saw Europe → the Decembrists |
| The Crimean defeat (1853–1856) | backwardness exposed → 1861 and the other Great Reforms |
| Half-finished reforms, the burden of ransom | the Narodniks and «People’s Will» → the murder of Alexander II (1881) |
| The assassination of 1881 | Alexander III’s counter-reforms, Russification |
- 1812
Russia’s Patriotic War
Borodino, the burning of Moscow, Napoleon’s retreat.
- 1814
Russian troops in Paris
- 1825
The Decembrist uprising
Senate Square, 14 December Old Style.
- 1830–1831
The Polish uprising is crushed
- 1833
Uvarov’s «Orthodoxy, autocracy, nationality»
- 1853–1856
The Crimean War
1853 — Sinop; 1854–1855 — the siege of Sevastopol.
- 1856
The Treaty of Paris
The Black Sea is neutralised.
- 1861
Serfdom is abolished
The manifesto is dated 19 February Old Style.
- 1864
The zemstvo and judicial reforms
- 1881
Alexander II is killed; counter-reforms begin
- 1891
Construction of the Trans-Siberian Railway begins
«They say that I am preparing to speak about the abolition of serfdom. I tell you: the present order cannot remain as it has always been. It is better to begin abolishing serfdom from above than to wait until it is abolished from below, by the peasants’ own action. You, the landowners, think about this and present me with your proposals. The matter cannot be dragged out.»
Source tasks
Problem
1) Identify the tsar whom the text does not name, the year of the speech and the reform it announces.
2) Explain one political and one economic cause of this reform.
3) Write two results of the reform that the text does not mention.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) Political: the Crimean defeat exposed backwardness and raised the danger of a peasant revolt «from below». Economic: serf labour was unproductive, and industry needed free labour and a market. Marks: two causes with explanation — 1; without explanation — ⅔; one with explanation — ½; one without — ⅓.
3) The peasants became free but had to pay a ransom and stayed bound to the commune; the zemstvo, judicial and military reforms followed; capitalism and railways grew. Marks: two results — 1; one — ½.
DİM task: chronology
Problem
Put the events in chronological order:
1. The abolition of serfdom
2. The battle of Borodino
3. The Treaty of Paris
4. The Decembrist uprising
5. The zemstvo and judicial reforms
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Step 2: Borodino — 1812 (2), the Decembrists — 1825 (4).
Step 3: the Treaty of Paris — 1856 (3), the peasant reform — 1861 (1), zemstvo and judicial reforms — 1864 (5).
Answer: 2, 4, 3, 1, 5.
DİM task: coded item
Problem
Choose the statements that relate to the peasant reform of 1861:
1. the peasants gained personal freedom
2. the land was given to the peasants free
3. ransom payments for the land were set
4. the village commune was kept
5. the peasants received the right to an elected State Duma
A) 1, 3
B) 1, 3, 4
C) 2, 4, 5
D) 1, 2, 4
E) 3, 4, 5
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Step 2: strike out 5 — the State Duma appeared only after 1905; E falls.
Step 3: of the remaining A and B, statement 4 is true (the commune was kept), so 1, 3, 4 is the full answer.
Answer: B.
Remember
- 1812 was a «victory not won in battle»: Borodino had no winner, and after Moscow cold, hunger and partisans destroyed Napoleon’s army.
- The Decembrists (1825) made the first open armed action of noble revolutionaries against autocracy and serfdom; Nicholas I answered with the Third Section and harsh censorship and abroad became «the gendarme of Europe».
- The Crimean War (1853–1856) ended with the Peace of Paris: the Black Sea was neutralised; the defeat exposed Russia’s backwardness.
- Alexander II abolished serfdom in 1861 (with ransom), followed by the zemstvo (1864), judicial (1864), municipal (1870) and military (1874) reforms.
- After the murder of Alexander II (1881) Alexander III pursued counter-reforms and Russification (the «prison of peoples»), while industry grew at the same time.