Aysel and Elvin solve the same equation: √(x + 2) = x. Both square the two sides: x + 2 = x², that is x² − x − 2 = 0, with roots x = 2 and x = −1. Aysel writes both numbers as the answer; Elvin checks them. For x = 2, √4 = 2 — true. For x = −1 the left side is √1 = 1 but the right side is −1: 1 ≠ −1. If there is no mistake in the calculation, where did −1 come from? In this lesson we uncover the secret of this “uninvited guest” and learn methods that keep such roots out of the answer.
Three things from earlier lessons will be needed: the definition of the arithmetic square root, √a ≥ 0 and (√a)² = a (“Square roots, nth roots and rational exponents”), solving quadratic equations (“Quadratic equations”), and finding domains and solving systems (“Quadratic inequalities and the interval method”).
Radical equations: the simplest case
Radical (irrational) equationDefinition
An equation in which the variable stands under a root sign: √(x + 2) = x, ∛(x − 1) = 2, √x + √(x − 5) = 5. The equation x√2 = 4 is not a radical equation: only a number stands under the root, not the variable.
Two properties of the square root work throughout this lesson. First, √f(x) makes sense only when f(x) ≥ 0 — this is the domain of the equation. Second, a square root is never negative, so an equation such as √(x + 1) = −2 has no solutions, without any calculation. If the root stands alone on one side and a number on the other, the equation takes one step.
Where
- f(x)
- the radicand (the expression under the root)
- a
- a number; for a square root with a < 0 there are no solutions
When a ≥ 0, squaring is safe: f(x) = a² ≥ 0, so the domain condition holds by itself. An odd root can have any sign, and cubing is an equivalent step — no extraneous roots appear.
The simplest equations
Problem
Solve: 1) √(2x − 3) = 5; 2) √(x² − 16) = 3; 3) √(x + 1) = −2; 4) ∛(x − 2) = −3; 5) 2√(x + 3) − 1 = 7.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) x² − 16 = 9 ⇒ x² = 25 ⇒ x = ±5. Both roots work: √9 = 3.
3) The left side cannot be negative, but the right side is −2: no solutions.
4) Cube both sides: x − 2 = (−3)³ = −27 ⇒ x = −25. An odd root may be negative; no check is needed.
5) First isolate the root: 2√(x + 3) = 8 ⇒ √(x + 3) = 4 ⇒ x + 3 = 16 ⇒ x = 13.
Squaring both sides and extraneous roots
Back to the secret from the start. If we square both sides of a true equality, we get a true equality again. The other direction does not work: 1² = (−1)², but 1 ≠ −1. Squaring “forgets” the signs of the sides. So the equation x + 2 = x² combines not one but two equations: √(x + 2) = x and −√(x + 2) = x. x = 2 is a root of the first, and x = −1 is a root of the second: −√(−1 + 2) = −1.
Imagine squaring as a machine that “eats” signs: 3² = 9, and (−3)² is also 9. When 9 comes out of the machine, we can no longer tell whether 3 or −3 went in. That is why the squared equation accepts the numbers at which the two sides are equal and also those at which they are opposite. Numbers of the second kind are the extraneous roots.
| x | √(x + 2) | right side x | squares | Is √(x + 2) = x true? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | 2 | 2 | 4 = 4 | yes |
| −1 | 1 | −1 | 1 = 1 | no: 1 ≠ −1 |
Where
- A, B
- the left and right sides of the equation (expressions)
Squaring works in one direction only: the new equation keeps all roots of the old one, but the roots of A = −B join them. Those are exactly the extraneous roots.
Extraneous rootDefinition
A number obtained while transforming an equation that does not satisfy the original equation. Extraneous roots appear in steps that widen the domain or raise both sides to an even power; we remove them by checking. Dividing by an expression with x works the other way: it can lose roots, and no check brings a lost root back.
Strictly speaking, solving an equation is a chain of transformations, and each of them is either equivalent (the set of roots does not change) or only a consequence (no root is lost, but extra ones may appear). The set of roots of A² = B² is the union of the roots of A = B and of A = −B — that is exactly the formula above. The table shows which steps are dangerous and why.
| Step | What can happen | Example |
|---|---|---|
| raising to an odd power, adding a number, multiplying by a non-zero number | nothing: the step is equivalent | ∛(x − 2) = −3 ⇔ x − 2 = −27 |
| squaring (any even power) | extraneous roots: the roots of A = −B join in | √(x + 2) = x → x = −1 |
| widening the domain (combining roots, cancelling) | extraneous roots outside the original domain | √x · √(x − 3) = 2 → √(x(x − 3)) = 2 → x = 4, x = −1 |
| dividing by an expression with x (narrowing the domain) | lost roots — no check brings them back | x + 1 = 2√(x + 1): dividing by √(x + 1) leaves only x = 3; x = −1 is lost |
Isolate the root
Leave only the root on one side; move everything else to the other side.
Square both sides
Square both sides. If the right side is a binomial, remember (a − b)² = a² − 2ab + b².
Solve the new equation
Usually it is a linear or a quadratic equation.
Check in the original equation
Substitute each root into the original equation. Checking in the squared equation is useless: the extraneous root satisfies it too.
Squaring and checking
Problem
Solve: 1) √(x + 2) = x; 2) √(2x + 7) = x + 2; 3) x − √(x + 1) = 5.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Check: √4 = 2 — true; √1 = 1 ≠ −1 — extraneous. Answer: x = 2.
2) 2x + 7 = x² + 4x + 4 ⇒ x² + 2x − 3 = 0 ⇒ x = 1 or x = −3.
Check: for x = 1, √9 = 3 = 1 + 2 — true; for x = −3, √1 = 1 but −3 + 2 = −1 — extraneous. Answer: x = 1.
3) Isolate the root: √(x + 1) = x − 5. Square: x + 1 = x² − 10x + 25 ⇒ x² − 11x + 24 = 0 ⇒ x = 3 or x = 8.
Check: 8 − √9 = 5 — true; 3 − √4 = 1 ≠ 5 — extraneous. Answer: x = 8.
Interactive
Solving without a check: an equivalent system
Checking is sometimes hard: a root may be an irrational number such as x = 2 + √3. Then it is easier to recognise extraneous roots in advance. They come from the equation −√f = g, so they appear where g(x) < 0. If we add the condition g(x) ≥ 0 to √f = g, squaring becomes an equivalent step.
A short rule: a root is never negative, so the side it equals cannot be negative either. In √(x + 2) = x the right side is x, so we write x ≥ 0 in advance. After squaring we get 2 and −1; −1 is negative, so we throw it away without substituting. This condition replaces the check and saves time, especially when a root is an “ugly” number like 2 + √3.
Where
- f(x)
- the radicand
- g(x)
- the other side of the equation
- g(x) ≥ 0
- the condition that removes extraneous roots in advance
There is no need to write f(x) ≥ 0: f(x) = g²(x) ≥ 0 holds by itself. g²(x) means (g(x))².
√f = g solved with a system
Problem
Solve: 1) √(5 − x) = x + 1; 2) √(2x² − 3x + 5) = x + 1; 3) √(2x) = x − 1.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) Condition: x ≥ −1. Equation: 2x² − 3x + 5 = x² + 2x + 1 ⇒ x² − 5x + 4 = 0 ⇒ x = 1 or x = 4. Both satisfy the condition. Answer: x = 1, x = 4 — squaring does not always produce an extraneous root.
3) Condition: x − 1 ≥ 0, so x ≥ 1. Equation: 2x = x² − 2x + 1 ⇒ x² − 4x + 1 = 0 ⇒ x = 2 ± √3. 2 − √3 ≈ 0.27 < 1 is rejected, 2 + √3 ≈ 3.73 ≥ 1. Answer: x = 2 + √3. A check by substitution would take much longer: √(4 + 2√3) = √((1 + √3)²) = 1 + √3.
When there is a root on both sides, we equate the radicands, but one of them must be non-negative — the other one then equals it automatically. When a product equals zero, the domain decides: if one factor is zero, the other one must still make sense.
Where
- g(x) ≥ 0
- the condition on the simpler of the two radicands (the other one equals it)
- f(x) · √g(x)
- a product with a root as one of its factors
In the product, the roots of f(x) = 0 count only inside the domain (g(x) ≥ 0).
Two roots and a product
Problem
Solve: 1) √(x² − 4) = √(3x); 2) √(x² − 2x) = √(x + 4); 3) (x + 2) · √(x − 1) = 0; 4) (x − 3) · √(x − 1) = 0.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) x² − 2x = x + 4 ⇒ x² − 3x − 4 = 0 ⇒ x = 4 or x = −1. The condition x + 4 ≥ 0 holds for both: √8 = √8, √3 = √3. Answer: x = 4, x = −1.
3) Domain: x ≥ 1. x + 2 = 0 ⇒ x = −2 lies outside the domain: √(−3) makes no sense. √(x − 1) = 0 ⇒ x = 1. Answer: x = 1.
4) Domain: x ≥ 1. Both x = 3 and x = 1 work. Answer: x = 1, x = 3.
Substitution and equations with two radicals
If the same root appears several times, or the expression under the root also appears outside it, we replace it with a new variable. A square root is never negative, so the new variable cannot be negative either — this condition removes negative values at once.
Where
- t
- the new variable
- t ≥ 0
- negative values of t are rejected
Solve the equation for t, reject negative values, then return to √f(x) = t. With roots such as ⁴√x, take t = ⁴√x, so √x = t².
Substitution
Problem
Solve: 1) x + √x − 6 = 0; 2) √x − 3 · ⁴√x + 2 = 0; 3) x² + 3x − 18 + 4√(x² + 3x − 6) = 0.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) t = ⁴√x ≥ 0, √x = t²: t² − 3t + 2 = 0 ⇒ t = 1 or t = 2. ⁴√x = 1 ⇒ x = 1; ⁴√x = 2 ⇒ x = 2⁴ = 16. Answer: x = 1, x = 16.
3) t = √(x² + 3x − 6) ≥ 0. Then x² + 3x = t² + 6 and x² + 3x − 18 = t² − 12. The equation becomes t² − 12 + 4t = 0 ⇒ t² + 4t − 12 = 0 ⇒ t = 2 or t = −6 (rejected). √(x² + 3x − 6) = 2 ⇒ x² + 3x − 10 = 0 ⇒ x = 2, x = −5. Both roots work, because t = 2 ≥ 0.
A perfect square under the root: a whole segment of roots
Problem
Solve √(x + 3 − 4√(x − 1)) + √(x + 8 − 6√(x − 1)) = 1.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
x + 3 − 4t = t² − 4t + 4 = (t − 2)², and x + 8 − 6t = t² − 6t + 9 = (t − 3)².
Since √(a²) = |a|, the equation becomes |t − 2| + |t − 3| = 1.
The distance from t to 2 plus the distance to 3 equals 1 exactly when 2 ≤ t ≤ 3 (outside this segment the sum is greater than 1).
2 ≤ √(x − 1) ≤ 3 ⇒ 4 ≤ x − 1 ≤ 9 ⇒ 5 ≤ x ≤ 10.
Check: x = 5 ⇒ √0 + √1 = 1 ✓; x = 10 ⇒ √1 + √0 = 1 ✓. An equation with infinitely many roots — the squaring method would get lost here.
With two roots in an equation, squaring once is not enough: (√a + √b)² = a + 2√(ab) + b, so a root remains. So we put the roots on different sides and square twice.
Squaring a sum of two roots does not get rid of the roots. Look at numbers: (√9 + √4)² = (3 + 2)² = 25, but 9 + 4 = 13 — the difference 12 = 2 · √36 is the “middle term”, and it contains a root. So we first put the roots on different sides: then after the first squaring only one root is left, and the second squaring removes it too.
Domain
Write ≥ 0 for each radicand and solve the system.
Separate the roots
Keep one root alone on one side and move the other to the other side.
First squaring
Square and isolate the remaining root again.
Second squaring and check
Square again, solve and check every root in the original equation.
Equations with two radicals
Problem
Solve: 1) √(x + 5) + √(x − 3) = 4; 2) √(2x + 3) − √(x + 1) = 1.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) Domain: x ≥ −1. √(2x + 3) = 1 + √(x + 1) — now both sides are non-negative. Square: 2x + 3 = 1 + 2√(x + 1) + x + 1 ⇒ x + 1 = 2√(x + 1). Let u = √(x + 1) ≥ 0: u² = 2u ⇒ u(u − 2) = 0 ⇒ u = 0 or u = 2 ⇒ x = −1 or x = 3. Check: √1 − √0 = 1, √9 − √4 = 1. Answer: x = −1, x = 3. Dividing by √(x + 1) would have lost the root x = −1.
The sum as a new variable
Problem
Solve √x + √(x + 7) + 2√(x² + 7x) = 35 − 2x.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
The equation becomes t + t² − 7 = 35 ⇒ t² + t − 42 = 0 ⇒ t = 6 (t = −7 < 0 is rejected).
√x + √(x + 7) = 6 ⇒ √(x + 7) = 6 − √x ⇒ x + 7 = 36 − 12√x + x ⇒ √x = 29/12 ⇒ x = 841/144.
The left side grows with x, so there is no other root. Check: √x = 29/12, √(x + 7) = √(1849/144) = 43/12, and 29/12 + 43/12 = 6 ✓.
Olympiad problems often use the estimation method: show that one side is never greater than some number M and the other side is never less than M. Then equality is possible only where both sides equal M at the same time. A useful estimate: for u, v ≥ 0, √u + √v ≤ √(2(u + v)), because (√u + √v)² = u + v + 2√(uv) ≤ 2(u + v). This is the inequality between the arithmetic and geometric means, 2√(uv) ≤ u + v, which follows from (√u − √v)² ≥ 0; at university it reappears as a special case of Jensen’s inequality.
The estimation method
Problem
Solve √(x − 2) + √(4 − x) = x² − 6x + 11.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Right side: x² − 6x + 11 = (x − 3)² + 2 ≥ 2.
Equality needs both sides to be 2: the right side is 2 only at x = 3, and there the left side is √1 + √1 = 2 ✓.
Answer: x = 3. Squaring twice would lead to an equation of degree 8.
The simplest radical inequalities
In inequalities a check does not help — there are usually infinitely many solutions. So every step must be equivalent. The key rule: of two non-negative numbers, the one with the larger square is larger, that is 0 ≤ a < b ⇔ a² < b². So we may square only when both sides are non-negative. And the domain must not be forgotten: f(x) ≥ 0.
An inequality usually has infinitely many solutions, so we cannot substitute and check them all. Keep two rules in mind: 1) the expression under the root cannot be negative; 2) square only when both sides are non-negative. With negative numbers squaring breaks the order: −3 < 2, but (−3)² = 9 > 4 = 2².
Think with numbers
Problem
Solve √(x − 2) < 3.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Try a few values: x = 6 ⇒ √4 = 2 < 3 ✓; x = 18 ⇒ √16 = 4 > 3 ✗; x = 0 ⇒ √(−2) — meaningless ✗.
So x runs from 2 (where the expression under the root is 0) up to 11, without 11: [2, 11). This is the solution of the system 0 ≤ x − 2 < 9.
Where
- a
- a positive number (non-negative in the second case)
- 0 ≤ f(x)
- the domain; it must not be forgotten in the “less than” case
When a < 0, √f(x) < a has no solutions, while √f(x) > a holds on the whole domain (f(x) ≥ 0). With ≤ and ≥ the case of equality is included too.
A root and a number
Problem
Solve: 1) √(x − 2) < 3; 2) √(2x + 1) ≥ 3; 3) √(x + 4) > −1; 4) √(3 − x) < −2; 5) √(x² − 3x) < 2.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) 2x + 1 ≥ 9 ⇒ x ≥ 4. Answer: [4, +∞).
3) The left side is ≥ 0 > −1, which is always true; only the domain matters: x + 4 ≥ 0. Answer: [−4, +∞).
4) A root cannot be less than a negative number: no solutions.
5) 0 ≤ x² − 3x < 4. x² − 3x ≥ 0 ⇒ x ≤ 0 or x ≥ 3; x² − 3x − 4 < 0 ⇒ (x − 4)(x + 1) < 0 ⇒ −1 < x < 4. Intersection: (−1, 0] ∪ [3, 4).
When the right side contains x, its sign is unknown, so we split into cases. In the “less than” case the right side must be positive, since it is greater than a non-negative root. In the “greater than” case there are two cases: if the right side is negative, the inequality holds on the whole domain; if it is non-negative, we may square.
Where
- f, g
- short for the expressions f(x) and g(x)
- { … }
- a system: all conditions hold together
In the second case we take the union (∪) of the solutions of the two systems. The condition f > g² also guarantees f ≥ 0.
A root and an expression with x
Problem
Solve: 1) √(x + 2) < x; 2) √(x + 2) > x; 3) √(x + 7) ≥ x + 1.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
2) Case I: x < 0 and x + 2 ≥ 0 ⇒ [−2, 0). Case II: x ≥ 0 and x + 2 > x² ⇒ x² − x − 2 < 0 ⇒ −1 < x < 2; with x ≥ 0 this gives [0, 2). Union: [−2, 2). Parts 1) and 2) complement each other, and at x = 2 there is equality (the root from the start of the lesson!).
3) Case I: x + 1 < 0 and x + 7 ≥ 0 ⇒ [−7, −1). Case II: x ≥ −1 and x + 7 ≥ (x + 1)² ⇒ x² + x − 6 ≤ 0 ⇒ −3 ≤ x ≤ 2; with x ≥ −1 this gives [−1, 2]. Union: [−7, 2].
Two DİM traps in inequalities
Problem
Solve: 1) √(x² − 3x + 2) ≥ x − 3; 2) (x − 3) · √(x² − 4) ≤ 0.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Case II: x ≥ 3 and x² − 3x + 2 ≥ x² − 6x + 9 ⇒ 3x ≥ 7 — true for every x ≥ 3 ⇒ [3, +∞).
Answer: (−∞, 1] ∪ [2, +∞). The trap is the gap (1, 2): the right side is negative there, yet the root makes no sense.
2) Domain: x ≤ −2 or x ≥ 2. At x = ±2 the product is 0 — both points are solutions. Elsewhere √(x² − 4) > 0, so we need x − 3 ≤ 0: on the ray x < −2 this always holds, and for x > 2 it gives 2 < x ≤ 3.
Answer: (−∞, −2] ∪ [2, 3]. Typical mistakes: losing the whole ray (−∞, −2] or the point x = −2.
- 1.√(x − 1) = 3 ⇒ x =
- 2.The extraneous root of √(x + 5) = x − 1 is x =
- 3.√(x + 3) < 2 ⇒ −3 ≤ x <
Remember
- √f(x) makes sense only for f(x) ≥ 0 and is never negative: √f(x) = a with a < 0 has no solutions, while ∛f(x) = a is equivalent to f(x) = a³.
- Squaring also brings in the roots of A = −B — these are extraneous roots; remove them by checking in the original equation.
- √f = g ⇔ {f = g², g ≥ 0} and √f = √g ⇔ {f = g, g ≥ 0} — with these systems no check is needed.
- For a repeated root use t = √f(x), t ≥ 0; with two roots, separate them, square twice and never divide by an expression with x.
- In inequalities square only when both sides are non-negative: √f < g ⇔ {f ≥ 0, g > 0, f < g²}; for √f > g solve the cases g < 0 and g ≥ 0 separately.