Sources and historiography: how historians verify facts

The material and written sources of Azerbaijan's history, archaeological dating (radiocarbon), converting Hijri dates and the steps of source criticism — with worked problems.

  • University
  • 25 min
  • 10 questions
  • Lesson 68 of 72

In this lesson you will learn

  • Classify sources by type and distinguish primary from secondary sources
  • Calculate a sample's age with the radiocarbon formula and interpret the result correctly
  • Convert a Hijri date to an approximate Gregorian date
  • Apply external and internal source criticism to a concrete case

Much of what we know about Babak's movement comes from his enemies — historians of the Abbasid Caliphate. How far can such sources be trusted? How did scientists establish that Azykh Cave is over a million years old? This lesson looks into the “kitchen” of historical science: how historians and archaeologists find, date and verify facts.

Types of sources

Historical sourceDefinition

Anything left from the past that gives information about it: a tool, a building, a coin, an inscription, a chronicle, a document, an epic. A primary source was created at the time of the event or by a participant; a secondary source is a later work based on primary sources.

Type of sourceWhat it tells usExample from Azerbaijan
Archaeological (material)Daily life, economy, technologyAzykh Cave, Kultepe, Gobustan
Epigraphic (inscriptions)Exact dates, names, constructionThe Roman legion's Latin inscription at Gobustan; inscriptions on mausoleums and mosques
Numismatic (coins)Rulers, mints, trade linksCoins of the Shirvanshahs and the khanates
Written (narrative)Course of events, the author's viewAssyrian inscriptions, Strabo, Movses Kalankatuatsi's History of the Country of Albania, al-Tabari
Folklore (oral)Values, customs, worldviewThe Book of Dede Korkut (Dresden and Vatican manuscripts)
The main types of historical sources.

Historiography is the history of what historians have written about the past. One of the founders of scholarly historiography in Azerbaijan was Abbasgulu Agha Bakikhanov: his Gulustani-Iram, written in Persian in 1841, explains the history of Shirvan and Dagestan by comparing different sources. Every historian asks the questions of his or her own time, so the same event may be interpreted differently in different centuries.

Sign up free to keep reading

The rest of the lesson, the quiz and your notes open with an Educora account. Signing up takes a minute, and your progress is saved on all your devices.

Archaeological dating and the radiocarbon method

Archaeology uses two kinds of dating. Relative dating shows which layer is older: in an undisturbed excavation, a lower layer is older than the one above it (the law of superposition, the basis of stratigraphy). Absolute dating gives an age in years. For materials from living organisms — bone, charcoal, wood — the most widely used absolute method is radiocarbon dating.

While an organism is alive, it takes in radioactive carbon-14 (¹⁴C) from the air and food. After death, ¹⁴C is no longer replaced and decays: about every 5,730 years its amount halves. This period is called the half-life. By measuring the fraction of ¹⁴C left in a sample, we can calculate the time since death.

N = N₀ · (½)^(t / T½) ⇔ t = T½ · log₂(N₀ / N)N = N₀ · (½)^(t / T½) ⇔ t = T½ · log₂(N₀ / N)

Where

N
amount of ¹⁴C left in the sample now
N₀
amount of ¹⁴C at the time of death
t
time since death, in years
T½
half-life of ¹⁴C ≈ 5,730 years

The law of radioactive decay: the amount halves every T½. The second form follows from the first by taking logarithms.

Example 1: whole half-lives

Problem

Charcoal from an ancient hearth retains 25% of its original ¹⁴C. When was the fire lit?

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

100% → 50% → 25%: two half-lives have passed.
t = 2 · 5730 = 11,460 years.
Check: N₀ / N = 4, log₂4 = 2 — same result.

Example 2: a fractional result and a “BP” date

Problem

Grains of cereal from a Bronze Age settlement retain 60% of their original ¹⁴C. Find the radiocarbon age and convert it to an approximate BC date.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

N₀ / N = 1 / 0.6 ≈ 1.667.
log₂1.667 = ln1.667 / ln2 ≈ 0.511 / 0.693 ≈ 0.737.
t ≈ 5730 · 0.737 ≈ 4,220 years BP.
Radiocarbon ages are counted back from 1950 by convention: 4220 − 1950 ≈ 2270 BC.
For an exact calendar date, the result is corrected with a calibration curve.

Written sources and Hijri dates

Many medieval Azerbaijani inscriptions, coins and chronicles are dated in the Hijri calendar. It begins in 622 (the Prophet Muhammad's migration from Mecca to Medina) and is a lunar calendar: a Hijri year is about 354 days, some 11 days shorter than a solar year. As a result, 33 Hijri years are roughly equal to 32 solar years.

M ≈ H − H / 33 + 622M ≈ H − H / 33 + 622

Where

M
Gregorian (AD) year
H
Hijri (AH) year

Derivation: a Hijri year is about 354 / 365 ≈ 32 / 33 of a solar year, so H Hijri years ≈ H · 32 / 33 = H − H / 33 solar years; 622 is the starting year. Accuracy ±1 year.

Example 3: dating an inscription

Problem

An inscription found in Shirvan says the building was completed in the Hijri year 839. Which Gregorian year is this?

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

H / 33 = 839 / 33 ≈ 25.4.
M ≈ 839 − 25.4 + 622 ≈ 1435.6.
A Hijri year spans two Gregorian years: 839 AH = 1435–1436 (the 15th century, when the Palace of the Shirvanshahs was being built).

Source criticism: how to verify a fact

  1. External criticism

    Is the source genuine? Who wrote it, when and where? Manuscript copies are compared, and the language and script are checked against the period.

  2. Internal criticism

    Was the author a witness? What was the purpose, and whom did the author serve? Look for signs of exaggeration and bias.

  3. Corroboration

    Is the fact confirmed by other independent sources — other chronicles, coins, archaeological finds?

  4. Conclusion

    Separate facts (dates, places) from the author's judgements; state the degree of certainty openly: “certain”, “probable”, “debated”.

Example 4: a source on Babak

Problem

One of the main written sources on Babak's movement is the chronicle of al-Tabari (died 923), who lived in Baghdad. How should this source be used?

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

External criticism: the author is known; the work was written in the Caliphate's capital about a century after the events — he was not a witness.
Internal criticism: the author reflects the Caliphate's viewpoint, so negative judgements about Babak may be biased.
Corroboration: the fall of Bazz in 837 and Babak's execution in Samarra in 838 also appear in other sources — these facts are reliable.
Conclusion: take the dates and the course of events, but treat the judgements critically.
  1. 9th–7th c. BC

    Assyrian inscriptions on Manna

  2. 1st century

    Strabo's Geography

  3. Early 10th century

    Al-Tabari's chronicle

  4. 1841

    Bakikhanov's Gulustani-Iram

  5. 1939

    Systematic study of Gobustan begins

  6. 1960

    Discovery of Azykh Cave

1 / 6

Remember

  • Sources are material, epigraphic, numismatic, written and oral; primary and secondary sources are distinguished.
  • Radiocarbon age: t = T½ · log₂(N₀ / N), T½ ≈ 5,730 years; BP counts from 1950, and the method works up to ≈ 50,000 years.
  • To convert a Hijri year: M ≈ H − H / 33 + 622; one Hijri year spans two Gregorian years.
  • Source criticism: external criticism → internal criticism → corroboration → separating facts from judgements.
  • Bakikhanov's Gulustani-Iram (1841) is one of the first works of scholarly historiography in Azerbaijan.
Spotted a mistake or something inaccurate in this lesson?

Check yourself

10 questions. Every correct answer earns XP.

Question 1 / 10

Question 1 / 10. A bone retains 12.5% of its original ¹⁴C. What is its approximate radiocarbon age?